/Users/forgebot/.hermes/outputs/kubota-cab-six-options/comparison.html
ForgeFX Simulations
KUBOTA / IMAGE-TO-3D EVIDENCE
SIX DISTINCT APPROACHES · ONE WHOLE-CAB SOURCE

Whole Cab Reconstruction
Provider Results & Geometry Review

No usable whole-cab winner. Five provider failures. One completed GLB, rejected for missing cab structure and distorted controls. This is an evidence comparison, not six finished models.

Option 01 uses Tripo 3.1 on the unchanged original image in one shot. Alternatives test dense Hunyuan, high-resolution TRELLIS, smart low-poly, segmented geometry and Hunyuan 3.0 low-poly quads.

Wallet: 7440.00 → 7385.00 credits. Net change: 55 credits. Failed attempts and retries are retained in the local manifest.

Original full-frame 4096-square Kubota cab source
Exact submitted composition. Hunyuan received a full-resolution JPEG re-encoding to meet its 8 MB limit. Source lineage: 5a28de3d-c62d-44b1-a233-14213b055472.
OPTION 01 / PROVIDER FAILED

Tripo 3.1 — Original One-Shot

No model returned

An error occurred on the provider side. Please try again later.

Mesh, triangle and texture statistics: unavailable.
No substitute geometry or empty 3D viewer.

Submission reached a terminal provider failure. The evidence record preserves task identity, request settings and earlier attempts.

Original unchanged PNG via hash-verified original ForgeMedia URL

Request settings & task
{
  "texture": true,
  "pbr": true,
  "texture_quality": "detailed",
  "geometry_quality": "detailed",
  "face_limit": 500000,
  "texture_alignment": "original_image",
  "enable_image_autofix": false,
  "export_uv": true,
  "quad": false,
  "smart_low_poly": false,
  "generate_parts": false
}

118dac53-feb5-4861-a03b-40ea296268ab

Open Failure Evidence

Record: 49439ba4-c7e8-4b1a-8141-d9e50d464300

OPTION 02 / PROVIDER FAILED

Hunyuan Pro 3.1 — Dense PBR

No model returned

Generation on the provider side timed out.

Mesh, triangle and texture statistics: unavailable.
No substitute geometry or empty 3D viewer.

Submission reached a terminal provider failure. The evidence record preserves task identity, request settings and earlier attempts.

Same uncropped 4096 square source, JPEG quality 95 4:4:4; provider 8MB size limit.

Request settings & task
{
  "model": "3.1",
  "enable_pbr": true,
  "face_count": 1500000,
  "generate_type": "Normal"
}

4125cc9c-2bda-496f-a01e-4f96f22c691f

Open Failure Evidence

Record: 304c2b8e-9b09-476b-b59b-7581a67bc399

OPTION 03 / REJECTED GEOMETRY

TRELLIS.2 — 1536 / 4K PBR

Loading real GLB…

492,397 triangles · 380,099 vertices
1 mesh · 1 material · 2 × 4096² texture images
21.65 MiB · 0 quads · 0 rigs / animations

Rejected as a whole-cab asset. Roof, upper enclosure and much of right console/display absent. Steering rim openings and three pedal pads survive, but controls are not separately operable objects. Warped panels, thin scraps and invented rear tractor-like bodywork. Single mesh, no rig or animation; scale, collision and engine readiness unverified.

Original unchanged PNG via hash-verified original ForgeMedia URL

Request settings & task
{
  "resolution": "1536",
  "steps": 16,
  "textures": true,
  "texture_size": 4096,
  "decimation_target": 2000000,
  "generate_thumbnail": false
}

92e1ad8a-2968-4540-9292-bd5324cdfb0e

Open ForgeMedia 3D Viewer Download GLB

Record: 1b220d51-8d04-42ad-ad87-88ba249eb969

OPTION 04 / PROVIDER FAILED

Tripo 3.1 — Smart Low-Poly

No model returned

An error occurred on the provider side. Please try again later.

Mesh, triangle and texture statistics: unavailable.
No substitute geometry or empty 3D viewer.

Submission reached a terminal provider failure. The evidence record preserves task identity, request settings and earlier attempts.

Original unchanged PNG via hash-verified original ForgeMedia URL

Request settings & task
{
  "texture": true,
  "pbr": true,
  "texture_quality": "detailed",
  "geometry_quality": "detailed",
  "face_limit": 40000,
  "texture_alignment": "original_image",
  "enable_image_autofix": false,
  "export_uv": true,
  "quad": false,
  "smart_low_poly": true,
  "generate_parts": false
}

28c20231-7486-4154-acdc-b2f23c69a468

Open Failure Evidence

Record: 39016839-09a7-433b-9431-80ba3b924226

OPTION 05 / PROVIDER FAILED

Tripo 3.1 — Segmented Geometry

No model returned

An error occurred on the provider side. Please try again later.

Mesh, triangle and texture statistics: unavailable.
No substitute geometry or empty 3D viewer.

Submission reached a terminal provider failure. The evidence record preserves task identity, request settings and earlier attempts.

Original unchanged PNG via hash-verified original ForgeMedia URL

Request settings & task
{
  "texture": false,
  "pbr": false,
  "texture_quality": "detailed",
  "geometry_quality": "detailed",
  "face_limit": 500000,
  "texture_alignment": "original_image",
  "enable_image_autofix": false,
  "export_uv": true,
  "quad": false,
  "smart_low_poly": false,
  "generate_parts": true
}

981de0c0-fe19-4752-8179-3999e949133a

Open Failure Evidence

Record: 5605e8bb-9ae6-48cd-943e-d5e8506b4bc3

OPTION 06 / PROVIDER FAILED

Hunyuan Pro 3.0 — Low-Poly Quads

No model returned

Generation on the provider side timed out.

Mesh, triangle and texture statistics: unavailable.
No substitute geometry or empty 3D viewer.

Submission reached a terminal provider failure. The evidence record preserves task identity, request settings and earlier attempts.

Same uncropped 4096 square source, JPEG quality 95 4:4:4; provider 8MB size limit.

Request settings & task
{
  "model": "3.0",
  "enable_pbr": true,
  "face_count": 40000,
  "generate_type": "LowPoly",
  "polygon_type": "quadrilateral"
}

0651d721-cdc0-42c9-9513-00601b2c6419

Open Failure Evidence

Record: 337e0c9e-1989-4d2a-bd0c-a2972da781d9

Rejected Evidence — Multi-Angle Blender Inspection

Camera labels use imported model axes, not verified vehicle coordinates. These renders expose a cropped dashboard/tractor-like reconstruction rather than a complete interior. Hidden geometry is inferred, not established by the source.

TRELLIS front inspection render
front
TRELLIS oblique inspection render
oblique
TRELLIS rear inspection render
rear

Readiness Findings

Steering-wheel openings and three pedal pads are visible. The roof, overhead console and complete pillar frame are absent. The right console and monitor are incomplete; the back is replaced by invented body panels and thin stretched sheets. All geometry is in one imported mesh object; no independently operable controls or animation rig were delivered.

Topology is triangular, not quad-based. UV-split vertex counts are not a watertightness test. Real-world scale, pivot, normals, collision, control separation and Unity/Unreal runtime performance have not been validated. Do not use this result for operator training.